Art, like the Greek pantheon, has apparently become completely irrelevant to the "public"-art, like the Greek gods, needs worship at the altar -to justify museums and masterpieces.
No one cares about the art, they seem to tell us.
What now for art?
No one cares, I think it says, in this new century, of art on walls.
Then I read this, by the guy formerly known as a leader against NCLB. Someone I truly respected for a petition he drove home to try to stop NCLB-he put his dissertation money where his mouth was.
And, no, I'm not going to argue, take on the points about tenure that infuriate me in that Huff Post piece (I hate the pop ups you deal with when hitting a Huff Post piece), not even here to discuss it. If tenure is lost to this kind of thinking, much like art lost to the fact we didn't teach it, or allow it, or "need it in the 21st century," we are rapidly getting a world I do not want for my children or grandchildren. I needed tenure to write this blog, to speak my truths and to pen the few good things I have here. If that has no value to another I cannot do more than I have to stand as representative of it.
I hope Philip was not abducted and a zombie is filling in. That would be a bummer.
BECAUSE I'm ready to do some writing to the Philip Kovacs.
I SHOULD have done it last year when I first read a letter he sent to his child's teacher-at the same grade level I was entering teaching. But I waited. I waited because last year presented challenges I could not publicly discuss, even WITH tenure.
And that may well be so this year. But this year I'm writing a response to Philip Kovacs, bit by bit, as I teach. And if you haven't read his letter to a teacher I'm taking on as about myself, then you should. Also it might make this make a little more sense...... because the "Dear Philips" that will follow here in my blog will be referencing that letter.
Dear Philip,
I started to write to you many times after reading your letter.
And then I waited a whole year and used it to help me through a very difficult school year where finding my way wasn't easy. I was just taking a Transitional Kindergarten, four year olds that turn five in the K year, and it was tough. For many reasons. But now, after a year under my 30 year teaching belt I'm going to take your letter to heart. I'm going to share with you what you said that's on my mind, and what I'm doing-as if you were both parent and listener.
Let's start with this, from your letter to your child's first teacher. Right now before I meet my class as I prep, it speaks to me. (Kids come in a week)
"I’d like him to end the year a little kinder, a little more courageous, and a little more compassionate."
Yes, Philip, that makes good sense to me as a place we can start.
Your child deserves a room where that is the way we do things. Last year, my first year in TK, at the start that was a challenge I did not see coming as a challenge. I so appreciate you said "end the year." Thank you. It takes time and whether you realize it or not I need the arc of time to do that work.
Children had anxiety last year entering to a level that shocks me still as I recall the days, children were acting out...and it took me awhile to achieve kindness as our value, but we did become kind, soft, and subtle. I was able to do so using my years of experience frankly, more so than in twenty years I think. I had to pull upon how to build relationships with each individual child. And establish trust. Ask for help for some, go to my District, allow others into the dynamics to help me. And I had to learn this age group again.
I just ordered a book, " Addressing Challenging Behaviors in Early Childhood Settings" by Dawn Denno, Victoria Carr and Susan Hart Bell- it's an inch thick and I'm starting it tonight hoping for thoughts on how to help children. It was recommended but I don't know yet.. I also spent the week remaking my room-thinking about kindness-and how we might start from day one building that together. How to have circle time, caring time. How to start the day in ways children will enjoy-less about the rigidity of the form.
I'm not a newcomer to this. But I can tell you that children last year struggled at first with all this.
And I was held "responsible," which took time.
It takes time to help children learn to wait their turn, offer friendship, share, not punch someone in the face.
But this year I'm going way slower and with rituals, rhymes, routines in our first months all about kindness.
You'd probably like that "Little Bear"- the videos -will be shown for ten minutes after we come in from outside play so we can cool down, have our restroom break, and see Little Bear demonstrate kindness.
So far I haven't seen something better or more reassuring. I gave myself permission to do that.
Would you like to see the room? I have changed a few things already from these pictures.
I'm rather pleased-we have a brand new carpet.
I've never worked in a more equipped room, not while teaching in public education. Plus add in I've got a lot organized from my storage-and spent thousands. Want to know what I want? I'll show you. I want these. I want to regularly use a puppet theater. (I pray it gets donated)
So here is the room.
(If I figured out the way to embed it.)

There is a book that I use personally as my "backstory" as I teach, it sits in my thoughts and I turn to it at the end of each day, especially in the area of kindness and care it's the backbone of my program, the foundation if you will. It is something that was written by someone on my Facebook if you want to know her, Greta Nagel. She's an incredible being.
The book is:
The Tao of Teaching: The Ageless Wisdom of Taoism and the Art of Teaching
She has one for parents as well. It is excellent, the only "parenting" book I recommend besides Dr. Spock and a great book Wonder Child, that you can get for a penny-so little. Penny for your thoughts I suppose. Oh and this one.
That might be some homework for you.
Right now I am in the week before my school starts, and I am thinking about the class as I once thought about my three children while they were in my womb.
We have yet to meet, but I am full of hope and nervousness and it all sits in my consciousness as the start of a journey. Doubting my abilities and decorating.
I'm reading the curriculum happily, as I once read those books I just recommended. Waiting for the days to come when I know I'll sleep very little, and find myself inadequate.
But I certainly will be back here to tell you how things are going, use a quote from your writing, and talk to you as if you were THAT father in my room,
My best,
Mrs. Puglisi
I had a strange experience yesterday both on my blog and on a PRIVATE FB. I wrote to Philip Kovacs on my blog here partially because I've engaged with him a long time, since 2006 when I'd already been writing about NCLB realities in my school for three or four years on Susan Ohanian's site. I read him so much as he framed a petition on-line and ran a group of many people I read discussing issues that really at their base were about the achievement gap. And teaching in lower socio-economic realities under a punishment model (as the rewards disappeared). So in my mind I "know" him-which is not really true. I admire him. He wrote a piece I linked to about teacher professionalism I find uneven. In addition he attacked tenure. I definitely do not hold those views and I don't want to debate the subject. I'm not going to "convince" anyone of that, much like years ago in my life I was in the unfortunate position of defending my students in South Central as a prof family friend basically entered a eugenics discussion. I'm just not going to defend a status I need to do public school work and in several districts I earned. Anyway a person, who friended me on FB , I assumed from West Virginia, SB came on leaving a note I thought did nor fit my blog piece.
ReplyDeleteHere it is.
SB (abbreviated) Speaking as a fellow teacher, I sense you take any bit of feedback that doesn't match your views 100 percent as a personal affront. As teachers, we should be open to what others say about our learning environment and profession. I hope you are a little more forgiving and less rigid with your students than you are with the Philip Kovacs of the world. You don't possess the only right opinion in the world when it comes to the teaching profession. Please don't take my comments personal. But, you should really try not to come across as the only voice of education. There are many of us who face the same challenges as you, but don't find it necessary to shoot down those who don't view the educational world through the same lens.
Yesterday at 10:55am · Edited
Sarah McIntosh-Puglisi I stand FOR tenure SB.
Like · 23 hrs
Sarah McIntosh-Puglisi For you and for my fellow teachers.
She then sent this message "privately on FB.
"Thank you, thank you, thank you for defriending me. Now I won't have to read post after post of your shit.
I'm ashamed to have you in the same profession. You are an embarrassment to teachers everywhere..SB "
That PRIVATE message I found offensive.
Sarah McIntosh-Puglisi I have removed you from my fb please direct your comments and reading to my blog SB.
On my blog she left this note.
"What a moonbat. You are Exhibit A as to why teachers should not be tenured. "
I had not removed her when I got the private message telling me I post messages that are shit.
I just had stated I was for tenure. I was at school and I was on my phone-tech not hooked up-I really don't quite know how to FB yet there to "remove folks". But I was GOING to do that at home because I just thought-this isn't a great Facebook relationship. After being told off I knew it wasn't good.
Frankly I don't really know this person. If we went to school together , sadly, I don't recall.
And she may have a point that I'm not able to take "feedback" though she has no working knowledge of me at all except lurking on a Facebook-I never saw posts of hers-there isn't a mutuality, nor did she ever engage with me. So to me this just was a bit too ...umm I think the word is uncomfortable. Anyway when I did unfriend and block her it ghosted this conversation on FB.
ReplyDeleteSo I will say this-I really like Philip Kovacs, admire his work, whatever he is doing will be cool in someway that helps the world-I am definitely going to use him as a foil to write to this year on my blog. Why? He represents the kind of parent I was and I never get in my room. It is blogging about the growing divide in socio-economics. I am thinking aloud. If it serves NO purpose it will help me evolve as a teacher-Philip KNOWS I'm doing it and I doubt it will affect him at all. I think he knows me enough to take the few jokes I embed into the writing or the few prods.
However if any of my dear friends here feel I'm just spewing garbage as she apparently did, and you aren't interested, you can de-friend, not read, run away, or just there are some settings that allow you to turn it off. That she is a teacher and did not do that already saddens me. I have no thought to weighing anyone down.
Sunday is the two year anniversary of my Mother's death in the two years before that my ONLY concern was her care. It's a huge moment for me. And for the most part all I've been doing is trying to heal. I loved her with all my heart-she was the person on earth I was closest to besides my children and Jack. I'm a strange gnome. A loyal one. I love for life. So no one I care about would I ever want to burden. That includes you!
Well it turns out this fb profile is a fake, not a teacher in Fairmont rather a person who has invented profiles before to tell me I do not belong in teaching. I tracked the ip addresses and was able to match the behavior with previous behavior and report it after documenting it to the family and family lawyer. It's interesting that he's used a Abu football players name and his work place and home ip addresses He got offended when I did not appreciate his commenting on a growing up in Morgantown page on fb and from that decided he'd characterize me. Instantly he began s campaign I did not belong in teaching and here we go with an ip not three miles from his Chicago address. Well DK I am reporting her profile and the ups as evidence to fb and certainly now I get it. I get it. You remain injurious, a bully, a liar, and sneaky. I will repeat to you ....stop bullying me
ReplyDeleteAbu was supposed to be WVU
ReplyDelete